Publications


MixItUp Demo - Toggle Filtering AND Logic



Reid on the Autonomy of Ethics: From Active Power to Moral Nonnaturalism

Journal of the American Philosophical Association, 2, 523-541, 2016


Status: Published

Citations:

Cite: [bibtex]


My Image

Abstract: Thomas Reid has the unusual distinction of arriving at a metaethical position very much like G. E. Moore's via a route very similar to that employed by the Kantians. That is, Reid embraces a version of nonnaturalist moral realism by appeal not to open question-style considerations but to a particular account of agency. In this essay, we reconstruct Reid's agency-centered argument for his constitutivist version of moral nonnaturalism, highlighting its commitments. Having presented Reid's argument, we close by considering a prominent contemporary Kantian view, namely, Christine Korsgaard's, and identifying where, despite their common commitments, Reid and Korsgaard part company. The comparison, we suggest, is instructive because it allows us to see more clearly why the link between agency-centered approaches to ethical theorizing and nonrealist, constitutivist views of morality, such as Korsgaard's, is deeply contingent.



[edit database entry]
Stacks Image 525289
(null)

  • Stacks Image 525371
    (null)
  • Stacks Image 525379
    (null)
  • Stacks Image 525375
    (null)


Stacks Image 525306
(null)

  • Stacks Image 525319
    (null)
  • Stacks Image 525314
    (null)
  • Stacks Image 525310
    (null)


Stacks Image 525327
(null)

  • Stacks Image 525331
    (null)
  • Stacks Image 525335
    (null)
  • Stacks Image 525339
    (null)


Stacks Image 525346
(null)

  • Stacks Image 525350
    (null)
  • Stacks Image 525354
    (null)
  • Stacks Image 525358
    (null)


Stacks Image 525386
(null)

  • Stacks Image 525390
    (null)
  • Stacks Image 525394
    (null)
  • Stacks Image 525398
    (null)